Federal judge rules in favor of Planned Parenthood - Your West Valley News: Elmirage

Federal judge rules in favor of Planned Parenthood

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Saturday, October 20, 2012 4:45 pm

PHOENIX -- A federal judge on Friday blocked lawmakers from cutting off family planning funds for Planned Parenthood solely because the organization also performs abortions.

Judge Neil Wake rejected arguments by attorneys for the state that it could cut off funding for family planning -- including federal Medicaid dollars -- by simply determining that abortion providers are not qualified. He said federal law gives Medicaid recipients the right to choose among all qualified providers "without government interference.'' And he said lawmakers cannot simply decide that Planned Parenthood is not a "qualified'' provider simply performs abortions outside the Medicaid program and without federal dollars.

"A state's determination of whether a provider is qualified must relate to its ability to deliver Medicaid services,'' Wake wrote in his 28-page ruling.

In fact, Wake pointed out that Steven Aden, a lawyer for the anti-abortion Alliance Defending Freedom, named a special assistant attorney general to defend the law, has never argued that Planned Parenthood is unqualified to perform family planning services. Instead, the state is saying Planned Parenthood can continue to be a family planning provider -- but only if it stops performing abortions or creates a separate legal entity.

That argument -- and the underlying law -- is based on the contention by state lawmakers that giving any public money to Planned Parenthood effectively subsidizes abortions.

As part of its participation in Medicaid, Arizona provides family planning services for needy women. The federal government picks up 90 percent of the cost, with the state covering the balance.

And both state and federal law specifically bar the use of public funds for abortions that are not medically necessary.

But Rep. Justin Olson, R-Mesa, who sponsored the legislation, said if the government gives money to help Planned Parenthood pay for its other expenses, that frees up that cash for abortions.

Wake was unpersuaded.

"This argument ignores evidence that Planned Parenthood Arizona complies with all federal and state requirements to ensure that public funds are not used for abortion services,'' the judge wrote, something he said is supported by the fact Planned Parenthood has participated in the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System, the state's Medicaid program, for more than 20 years.

And Wake noted that Planned Parenthood is a "fee for service'' provider, meaning it bills AHCCCS only for the specific services it provides to patients.

Wake's ruling is not a final word on the law but simply bars the state from enforcing it while the issues are litigated. But the judge said it was necessary to issue the injunction to ensure that that patients can continue to see the health care providers of choice while that fight goes on.

Olson said he is "disappointed'' by the ruling, saying he anticipates an appeal. Nor is giving up on efforts to cut public funds for Planned Parenthood.

"I will continue to push the envelope for the unborn and to continue to protect the taxpayers from the procedures they find reprehensible,'' he said.

Olson also dismissed Wake's finding that there was no evidence of cross-subsidization of abortion.

"We don't have convincingly strong evidence there is not,'' he said.

He conceded that would involve requiring Planned Parenthood to prove a negative. And he said if that's impossible, that's the reason for the law in the first place.

"Round One goes to Planned Parenthood,'' said Cathi Herrod. She is president of the Center for Arizona Policy which helped craft the legislation.

  • Discuss

Welcome to the discussion.

1 comment:

  • realsolutions posted at 9:24 am on Thu, Oct 25, 2012.

    realsolutions Posts: 1

    They continue to try and push women backward. Let women make their own choices and do not deprive them of any services they may need. TRUST WOMEN-protect choice.


Wild Horse West

Tell Us What You Think!


The 30 Safest Cities to Raise a Child

Raising children is stressful enough without having to worry about their safety. Luckily, there are a number of cities across America that are…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 3:40 pm @ http://www.safewise.com/blog/safest-cities-to-rais…

Amazon: what to watch in July

Amazon’ing and chilling this month? There’s plenty to get your teeth into on the site over the next few weeks. Here are the highlights – movie…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 3:27 pm @ http://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/amazon…

Movies in a Minute: 'The Big Friendly Giant'

I went into “The Big Friendly Giant” — “The BFG” for all those who swear by the book — pretty blind and, I have to admit, it really doesn’t li…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 3:26 pm @ http://ktar.com/story/1153746/movies-in-a-minute-t…

Phoenix City Council OKs property-tax hike for residents

PHOENIX - For the first time in 20 years, property taxes are going up for Phoenix residents. The Phoenix City Council voted 5-4 Friday to appr…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 3:11 pm @ http://www.abc15.com/news/region-phoenix-metro/cen…

Partybaby face forward in their 'I Don't Wanna Wait' video

Impatient ‘til the end, Partybaby’s new ‘I Don’t Wanna Wait’ video wastes no time with pleasantries. All 100mph pace and massive, sky-scraping…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 3:12 pm @ http://diymag.com/2016/06/30/partybaby-i-dont-wann…

Attorney general Loretta Lynch regrets meeting with Bill Clinton

PHOENIX - Attorney General Loretta Lynch acknowledged Friday that her meeting with Bill Clinton while his wife is under federal investigation …

Published: July 1, 2016 - 2:57 pm @ http://www.abc15.com/news/region-phoenix-metro/cen…

Here's What's New To All Of The Streaming Platforms In July

It's going to be hot this July, so instead of sitting in traffic on your way to the beach or melting while hiking, why not just Netflix (or Am…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 2:57 pm @ http://laist.com/2016/07/01/streaming_guide_july_2016.php

Phoenix city council OKs property tax hike

PHOENIX (KPHO/KTVK) - In an emotional 5-4 vote, a divided Phoenix City Council approved the city’s first property tax hike in 21 years. So man…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 2:39 pm @ http://www.azfamily.com/story/32355971/packed-hous…

Phoenix ties all-time record for June average temperature

It was more than toasty outside in Phoenix last month, even based on the Valley’s standards. It seemed nearly once or twice a week in the mont…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 1:58 pm @ http://ktar.com/story/1154716/phoenix-ties-all-tim…

Heavy rain, flash flooding expected around Tucson

TUCSON - The Tucson area is under a flash flood warning as a storm that has already brought an inch of rain continues. The National Weather Se…

Published: July 1, 2016 - 1:57 pm @ http://www.abc15.com/news/region-central-southern-…


YourWestValley.com on Facebook


YourWestValley.com on Twitter


Subscribe to YourWestValley.com via RSS

RSS Feeds