Sen. Burges challenges opponent's residency in LD-22, Muscato wants debate - Your West Valley News: Elections

Sen. Burges challenges opponent's residency in LD-22, Muscato wants debate

Print
Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Tuesday, October 18, 2016 12:15 pm

State Sen. Judy Burges has formally requested that state officials investigate whether her opponent in the upcoming general election lives outside of District 22.

In letters to State Attorney General Mark Brnovich and the Arizona Clean Elections Commission, Ms. Burges, R-Sun City West, indicates that Michael Muscato owns a residential property in Anthem, which is outside of LD-22.

The letters suggest Mr. Muscato’s claim as a resident of LD-22 is contradicted by a document filed with Maricopa County in order to receive favorable tax treatment on the Anthem property. Primary residences qualify for lower rates than secondary or investment properties.

The Arizona Revised Statutes, Section 16-311(A),(B) states: “At the time of filing, a candidate for public office must be a qualified elector and must reside in the county, district or precinct that the candidate proposes to represent.”

Ms. Burges’ attorney, Timothy La Sota, submitted the letters, including documentation of both of Mr. Muscato’s addresses of residence.

Mr. Muscato has stated he does not live outside the district, currently residing in Peoria.

“This attack against Michael Muscato by Judy Burges is nothing more than a blatant attempt to attack his integrity and to embarrass him just as voting in the 2016 election commences,” read a statement in response to Ms. Burges’ actions. “She will stoop as low as necessary to win.”

Mr. Muscato has stated that he lives at 9601 W. Cielo Grande in Peoria with his parents, his wife, Alicia, and two children. He considers this his primary residence. He attended public school within that area and owns a business in Glendale.

Mr. Muscato stated he purchased his property at 224 W. Ridgecrest Road in Phoenix as an investment property. Documents show he bought the home June 2015 at a sale price of $375,000. The document also indicates the property as a primary residence.

The letters ask Mr. Brnovich and the Clean Elections Commission to determine whether Mr. Muscato is a resident of LD-22. If he is, then did his filing of the Anthem property as his residence violate A.R.S. Section 39-161? Further, did he receive illegal property tax benefits that need to be repaid to Maricopa County?

But if he is not a resident of LD-22, the letters ask officials to decide whether Mr. Muscato violated the statutes by filing a nomination paper and application for certification with Arizona Secretary of State Michele Reagan, who was also made aware of the situation.

“At a minimum Mr. Muscato must repay the ill-gotten property tax benefit he has received through the erroneous property declaration he filed, but the evidence is mounting that he is not a real resident of Legislative District 22, and there will undoubtedly be more to this story,” Ms. Burges said in a statement.

Mr. Muscato has asked to debate Ms. Burges prior to the election but she has declined to do so. He attempted to attend the LD-22 Republicans Group meeting on Oct. 17 to bring up that proposal again. However, less than 15 minutes after arriving, he was told by the group’s chairman to leave.

“She is welcome to come over for dinner anytime,” he has stated several times via email.

Mr. Muscato also said Ms. Burges had declined to a Clean Elections debate for a second straight election. He released a video after the commission informed him of her response, saying he would meet Ms. Burges and her campaign at any time and place.

“I also asked them (LD-22 Repbulicans) at the recent Sun City Grand fall festival,” Mr. Muscato said via text. “Several Republican members there said they’d love a debate and the heads of the club said ‘no way.’”

The Surprise Chamber of Commerce did the same thing, he added.

“Leaders don’t hide, they hold people accountable and stand up for the people they represent,” Mr. Muscato said. “I’m going to fight for my hometown until the very end and I hope that the voters will do the same for me Nov. 8.”

Independent Newsmedia has contacted the Arizona Clean Elections Commission seeking comment.

Contact Chris Caraveo at ccaraveo@newszap.com or 623-876-2531.

  • Discuss

Tell Us What You Think!

Loading…

Michelle Dionisio Farewell

  • Dunkin' Donuts opens Friday in Surprise with deal, donations

    Dunkin’ Donuts will open a new restaurant in Surprise at 13953 W. Waddell Road on Friday.To celebrate the grand opening, the restaurant will be offering 50 cent cups of medium hot and iced coffee from Friday through Sunday. 100 percent of the proceeds from coffee sold during these dates will be donated to Make-A-Wish Arizona.Make-A-Wish Arizona grants the wishes of Arizona children with life-threatening medical conditions to enrich the human experience with hope, strength and joy.“We are so pleased that Dunkin’ Donuts reached out to our chapter with this special opening offer to benefit our wish kids,” said Elizabeth Reich, president and CEO of Make-A-Wish Arizona. “With more than 450 Arizona children waiting for their wish, partnerships like these are what helps make wishes come true.”In addition, the Willow Canyon High School band will be on site to pump up to crowd. Free samples and a prize wheel will also be included.The new restaurant will be open from 4 a.m. to 11 p.m. daily a week and will employ approximately 30 crew members. The restaurant will have comfortable seating.

  • Small infill development selling soon in east Surprise

    South Gate, a housing development in its initial stages, is quite unlike most other new homes under construction in Surprise.It is small and completely new rather than an additional phase of a large master plan like Marley Park or a concept recently restarted after the housing crisis like Asante. And SouthGate is not in a new home hot spot — rather it is in a more commercial area in Surprise’s eastern tip.One of the first examples of infill development in the young city, this Garrett-Walker Homes development is still in the fairly early stages of construction, with exterior community walls just going up and lots being graded directly north of Quik Trip at 11420 W. Bell Road and west of Barnaby Street Shoppes and 5 and Diner.“The original plan for the SouthGate property was for commercial, then it was changed to high-density residential, then back to commercial again, then again changed to high-density residential and now is at a medium-density residential designation with the SouthGate project. It’s a positive for the city when infill development occurs and parcels like this are developing,” Community Development Director Eric Fitzer said.Mr. Fitzer said there are a total of 49 lots in SouthGate.Scott Raney, director of product design and development for Garrett-Walker, said single-family homes at SouthGate will range from 1,300 to 3,000 square feet.

  • Traffic collision in Surprise near Greenway and Cotton

    Surprise Police are currently at the scene of a traffic collision with reported injuries in the area of Greenway Road and Cotton Lane.Upon arrival, police discovered two vehicles were involved in the collision. The Surprise Fire and Medical Department are at the location and are evaluating the occupants for possible injuries. Expect minor traffic delays while travelling through the area as police continue to investigate the cause of the collision and the remove the damaged vehicles from the roadway.

  • Silver Alert cancelled, Peoria man returns home safe

    A Peoria man who went missing Wednesday afternoon has returned home and is safe. The Silver Alert has been cancelled.William Hathcox had last been seen at his home in the 8900 block of N. 105th Lane at about 1:30 p.m. Wednesday. He left driving a silver 2007 Dodge Caravan with Arizona license plate ALR2771. He did not tell anyone where he was going and would not be able to navigate through the city. Mr. Hathcox has severe Alzheimer's.

  • SCHOA calls for sign changes

    The Sun City Home Owners Association Board of Directors put its weight behind a request to remove four stop signs on 103rd Avenue in the community’s phase one.After hearing SCHOA Roads and Safety Committee and residents requests in October, Maricopa County Department of Transportation officials agreed to study the options to change the look of four-way stop intersections on 103rd Avenue at Alabama Avenue and Sun City Boulevard. The SCHOA board upped the ante with a written request to MCDOT leadership and Clint Hickman, Maricopa County District 4 supervisor.Residents believe the signs create confusion for drivers and, therefore, are a safety hazard.“People come up to those signs and, because the streets are wider than standard, they believe it marks a two-lane street,” said Don Thompson, Sun City Home Owners Association board member.There are stop signs in the middle of the travel lane northbound and southbound on 103rd Avenue, in addition to signs on the northwest and southeast corners of the intersection. The street also includes wedge-shaped white lines leading from the signs back toward oncoming traffic. While it, and other Sun City roadways, was built wider than standard 12-foot lane streets, 103rd Avenue is a single travel lane in each direction, according to Mike Alberston, MCDOT project manager.Mr. Thompson suggested moving the stop signs to the center line of the street. However, Mr. Albertson believes that will create more of a safety issue.

  • Ventana Lakes supports Valley View

    Ventana Lakes residents in Peoria did their part to support the Valley View Community Food Bank.The community hosted a fundraising dinner Nov. 19. A pasta dinner and penny auction were conducted at the Yacht Club, 20015 N. 108th Lane, with more than 130 attending.Residents of the Peoria age-restricted community already contribute nonperishable food items to the food bank that serves a wide area of the West Valley and beyond. Residents Tony and Evelyn DeMont coordinate the collection of donated food weekly from the Ventana Lakes community and deliver them to the Food Bank. They approached residents Kathy and Fred Freda in september about hosting a fundraising event and they eagerly agreed.A penny auction was added, including items donated from community residents.Mr. and Mrs. Freda presented Jesse Ramirez, food bank director and founder, with an initial contribution of $1,200 raised from the dinner proceeds. However, he was not able to stay to the end of the event to see that another $800 was raised in the penny auction.“The generosity of all Ventana Lakes residents present was overwhelming,” Ms. Freda said.

  • 7 people involved in traffic collision in north Peoria

    Seven people were involved in a traffic collision in northwest Peoria near the Loop 303.One person was transported to the hospital in serious condition, according to a North County Fire-Medical Department spokesperson.The collision involved four vehicles on the east side of the Loop 303 on Happy Valley Parkway.Three other people with minor injuries delayed transportation to the hospital, according to North County. Another three with minor to no injuries declined to be transported.Traffic is moving in both directions on Happy Valley Parkway but each are restricted to one lane.Units from the North County and Peoria Fire-Medical departments assisted, and Maricopa County Sheriff's Office deputies were on the scene to investigate the cause.

  • Chick-Fil-A, American Legion Auxiliary team with Soldier’s Best Friend

    Arrowhead Chick-Fil-A and Peoria’s American Legion Auxiliary Unit 62 have teamed up to sponsor an Arizona veteran with a “comfort dog” through Soldier’s Best Friend.With their training facility in Peoria, Soldier’s Best Friend pairs Arizona veterans who have been diagnosed with post traumatic stress disorder or traumatic brain injury with a rescue dog — “touching two lives at once.”While there is no cost to the veteran, the cost of the program is $4,000 per pair. Both the veteran and dog go through extensive training. In honor of the World War I peace treaty signed at 11 a.m. on the 11th day of the 11th month, Chick-Fil-A donated 11 percent of sales on Veteran’s Day to the Auxiliary, covering more than half the cost of a sponsorship.Soldier’s Best Friend is a special emphasis this year for the Department of Arizona’s Auxiliary president, Jan Cushing. As a result, Unit 62 will apply the donated funds and has raised the rest of the funds needed to sponsor a veteran and companion.“We love partnering with Peoria’s Auxiliary,” explained Leo Lichter, Glendale resident and owner/operator of the Arrowhead Chick-Fil-A at 83rd Avenue and Bell Road. “They are in touch with opportunities to make a difference in the lives of military and veterans and we are pleased to be part of the wonderful things they do.”Unit 62 recently worked with Major League Baseball to conduct a Veteran’s Day tribute at a fall league game at the Peoria Sports Complex. More than 1,000 spectators were greeted with American flags and “In Memorium” poppies distributed by American Legion Auxiliary Juniors, Sons of the American Legion and Dysart High School JROTC members. Complimentary tickets were distributed to veterans by west valley American Legion posts, Arrowhead Chick-Fil-A and the office of Mayor Cathy Carlat, among others.

  • Valley View fundraiser set for holiday food

    Valley View Community Food Bank officials are hoping to raise additional funds for holiday food items.The fundraising dinner is 5 p.m. Sunday, Dec. 11 at Sunset Bistro, 15462 N. 99th Ave., Sun City. The dinner will include finger food items, according to Jesse Ramirez, Valley View director. Tickets for the event are $10 and are availabel at the Valley View thrift stores in Sun City and Sun City West.The fundraiser will also include a silent auction for numerous items donated by area businesses and residents.“There is a brand new organ, donated by Fletcher’s, and some vacations, along with a lot of other things,” Mr. Ramirez said.The fundraiser is an attempt to raise money to purchase additional holiday food items like ham, according to Mr. Ramirez. The food bank is seeing a steady increase in clients at its distribution locations in El Mirage and Sun City, he added.

  • Glendale gives grass, tree maintenance tips for winter

    Have you noticed some turf areas in the Valley have turned brown? Don’t panic. Grass and trees aren’t dying – just going into dormancy.Like a hibernating bear, brown Bermuda grass is actually going through a natural, healthy process. In fact, some experts suggest that allowing dormant grass to go brown without overseeding can lead to a better lawn the following summer.Still, even a sleeping lawn needs care. Glendale keeps winter grass in top condition with the following methods:• Keep the lawn care schedule fairly normal in October (mow, fertilize, water). As the month progresses, cut back on the irrigation schedule gradually until watering about once a week.• Once November hits, limit watering to a half cycle, once a week through March. Mow once a month during this time, but don’t fertilize.• Limit activity on the dormant Bermuda grass. The grass is weak, so bare spots can develop easily.

  • Man dies from injuries in Tuesday's crash in Glendale

    A man died from injuries he sustained in a crash in Glendale on Tuesday, officials stated in a release.On Dec. 6 at about 2 a.m., Glendale Police responded to a two-vehicle collision at the intersection of Peoria and 51st avenues. The Glendale Fire Department also responded to treat those injured.Four people were transported to local hospitals with varying injuries, according to police.Poe Glay, 45 of Phoenix, was later pronounced deceased due to the injuries from the accident. The other three involved in the crash sustained non-life threatening injuries.The Glendale Vehicular Crimes Detectives assumed the lead on the investigation which so far has revealed that a red sedan, driven by Mr. Glay with a female passenger, was traveling eastbound on West Peoria Avenue. Mr. Glay was passing through the intersection when his vehicle was struck by a gray SUV traveling southbound on North 51st Avenue. The accident caused the SUV to flip over and pushed the sedan into the bus lane, police stated.Two people occupied the SUV, including the driver Jodie Ramsey, 22 and a female passenger. Both were transported to the hospital. Ms. Ramsey did show signs of impairment at the scene, according to officials.

  • FBI looks for Packing Pigeon Bandit after Glendale robbery Monday

    The FBI is looking for a suspect known as the Packing Pigeon Bandit after he robbed a Glendale bank at gunpoint earlier this week.On Monday, Dec. 5 at about 12:50 p.m., a man robbed the Arizona Central Credit Union, 6901 W. Bell Road in Glendale.The man ordered multiple individuals inside to the floor and pointed a silver handgun at them. The suspect was wearing a black ski mask. The suspect walked up to the teller counter, showed a gun and demanded money before fleeing with an unknown amount of U.S. currency.The suspect is described as a white male, 6-feet tall with a stocky build. He is believed to be in his 40's or 50's, with gray hair and a moustache. He was wearing a blue sweatshirt with a gray shirt underneath and black parachute pants. The suspect was last seen leaving westbound from 71st Avenue and Juniper in a small-to-mid-size gold or tan late-model SUV. No one was physically injured during the robbery.He is dubbed the "Packing Pigeon Bandit" because he displayed a silver handgun during the bank robbery and he appears to walk pigeon toed.The FBI is offering a reward of up to $1,000 for information leading to the arrest of this man.He is considered armed and dangerous.Contact the Phoenix Office of the FBI at 623-466-1999 for any information on this crime.If you have any information concerning this case, please contact your local FBI Office or the nearest American Embassy or Consulate. You can also submit a tip at tips.fbi.gov.

  • 7 people involved in traffic collision in north Peoria

    Seven people were involved in a traffic collision in northwest Peoria near the Loop 303.One person was transported to the hospital in serious condition, according to a North County Fire-Medical Department spokesperson.The collision involved four vehicles on the east side of the Loop 303 on Happy Valley Parkway.Three other people with minor injuries delayed transportation to the hospital, according to North County. Another three with minor to no injuries declined to be transported.Traffic is moving in both directions on Happy Valley Parkway but each are restricted to one lane.Units from the North County and Peoria Fire-Medical departments assisted, and Maricopa County Sheriff's Office deputies were on the scene to investigate the cause.

  • City, police work through negotiations amicably, ahead of schedule

    Contract negotiations between Peoria and the police union over wages, hours and work conditions have come to a close amicably and ahead of schedule.The City Council approved a four-year agreement with the City of Peoria Police Supervisors that takes effect July 1, 2017 to June 30, 2021.The new agreement retains the current pay structure, but establishes a new sick leave payout program. The contract also provides $1,000 in professional development pay, and one additional personal day for the life of the agreement.“It was very important to us that (the union) came to the table with a strategy and a very reasonable attitude and a desire to work with the city and find a way for everybody to come out a winner,” Mayor Cathy Carlat said. “And it certainty looks like that is the result here.”The cost of the four-year contract to tax payers ranges from $111,469 to $114,422 per year, depending on the individual members’ use of the benefits as provided.Lead negotiator Sgt. Ed Bakke said the contract was approved by every union member.

  • Silver Alert cancelled, Peoria man returns home safe

    A Peoria man who went missing Wednesday afternoon has returned home and is safe. The Silver Alert has been cancelled.William Hathcox had last been seen at his home in the 8900 block of N. 105th Lane at about 1:30 p.m. Wednesday. He left driving a silver 2007 Dodge Caravan with Arizona license plate ALR2771. He did not tell anyone where he was going and would not be able to navigate through the city. Mr. Hathcox has severe Alzheimer's.

Tell Us What You Think!

Loading…